Doctors not Listening
"I was diagnosed HIV Positive in Feb 2002. I’ve always believed in the holistic approach to illnesses, and years ago threw Prozac I was prescribed down the toilet. At the time of my HIV diagnosis I had a good friend who supported me. He also had a strong holistic approach. For someone who hardly ever went to the doctors having to go to the hospital twice every 3 months to have blood tests done was very stressful but my friend said, "Go with your sunglasses on, and hold your head up high", that really helped.
I maintained a positive attitude, but when I went to see the doctor and told him I had an alternative approach, within a matter of minutes he tried to destroy my ‘positivity’ and told me virtually that there is no point having that attitude and, "Do you know how serious this is?" and how someone who thought like me and had a holistic approach is now in a wheel chair.
At the time I was quite vulnerable, and hearing that crushed me a bit. After that I went to the hospital in tears. I did maintain my health regime though and a year later My CD4 count went up from 250 to 650. Instead of encouraging me the doctor said the result must be a mistake and again I felt crushed. It seemed when the counts when down it predicted doom, but when they went up it was an error, so there was no way out.
Since then I stopped taking care, and my CD4 count has been as low as 190. Every time I go to the doctor’s I feel they pressurise me to go on their drugs and when I tell them I don’t wish to they say, "Well, eventually you'll have to".
This has all felt an enormous pressure, for as well as having to deal with the other issues that go with being diagnosed with a so-called terminal disease, I feel that my views are not being recognised, and really felt alone with this. I went to other support groups that had the normal beliefs about AIDS, and the people there also said the same thing. I felt I was alone in this battle, until I discovered HEAL London. It was a relief to know that there were some intelligent people out there that think ‘out-side the box’ and that I was not alone in my views.
I don’t feel any support from the medical profession, as they are so one-sided in their views; They don’t support any patients who go against them, and don’t listen to them as a holistic being but just see them as a statistic, and it feels like they can’t wait for them to take their meds. This has made me lose more trust in medical professionals.
Apart from the diagnosis, physically, but for a few rashes, (which they also blame on the HIV) i have been in good health. But the psychological effects have been imense, and deterimental to progressing in my life in most areas."
SB
(heterosexual, non-drug-using female)
A health professional comments:
Your experience of not being listened to by medical professionals is a very common one but of course I realise that that doesn't minimise the lack of consideration that you have personally experienced. As I'm sure you now know, there are many explanations as to why your test showed 'positive' other than the official explanation forced on you.
You rightly took care of your own health but you have found this difficult whilst being in contact with medical professionals who are trained to reduce people's life experiences into some form of statistic ('CD4'/'Viral Load' etc); to dismiss people's own explanations about their own health; and to pressurise people into certain forms of behaviour and accepting pharma treatments.
| < Prev |
|---|



Comments
.. and believe me there are 1000s, is not science, its misrepresentati on.
Would you just name ONE or TWO please?
er... no, I would rather not believe you.
Same old story: there are thousands... Why don't you just tell us one then.
This is not a competion, but real Lives.
It just seem like once we are diagnosed we are non-people but just statistics, in the middle between scientific arguments... But hang on we are here too.. Listen to real people! Ask them how they are doing, and what they want...
or don't we have a choice??
SB
a) So, everyone in the world who does not have a HIV positive diagnosis is fit and healthy??? I wonder what is the source of this incredible assertion.
b) Ditto. I would love to see some evidence for this.
Hi sorry to hear the 'drugs' caused you problems, but i'm so glad that you did some research and now are off them.. I hope you will intime recover from the ill-effects of the 'Drugs'
Yes they do operate very cleverly and put fear into many people, also many people who are diagnosed are 'ill' at the time, and ofcourse with any illness the immune system is already weak...so this in turn causes a false positive anti-body result!! Its all very cleverly controlled.
Thankyou for your encouragement.
All the best.
SB
You make all this sound like a competion, who dies first those on ARV's or those not...
This is not a competion, but real Lives.
It just seem like once we are diagnosed we are non-people but just statistics, in the middle between scientific arguments... But hang on we are here too.. Listen to real people! Ask them how they are doing, and what they want...
or don't we have a choice??
SB
I just don't like the pressure that doctor's put on people and the fear tac-tics involved.. I mean to be told every few months (when you feel great) that in a few months time you'll get ill and be in a wheel chair unless you take the ARV's is not very encouraging or helpful. Many people then do 'give in' to the drugs out of that fear and do become ill, (from the side effects) which is then blamed on the HIV and the 'drugs' not working.
SB
Your first comment says it all 'what they think is best' what about how a patient feels? is that not important?
You say the vast majority of people with low CD4 counts dont remain well, well it is a fact that CD 4 counts don't necessarilly measure health and many people even with low counts are doing very well. I myself apart from a few 'minor' infections have remained very well. I do believe that there are many other's ways to prolong a healthy life, and ARV's are not the only answer. Many other factor's that contribute to a holistic way of health should in my opinion also be taken into consideration... but these are ignored by the medical professionals.
In contrary to what you have seen, I have in over 8 years now seen many people pass away that have been on the arv's. I believe that maybe linked to an over load of toxins in their system.
The people I know who are not on the 'drugs' are doing great.
To question evidence is wise, to dismiss evidence to further your own point is madness.
One study you quoted showed an increase in mortality on HAART, there are 1000s that show a decrease, absolutely hundreds.
It is frightening the number of people that seem to believe this 'psuedo' evidence it really is, at the end of the day it is each individual patients choice to choose what they decide to do, after all it is their bodies. But to totally disregard any studies that do not support your own opinion, and believe me there are 1000s, is not science, its misrepresentati on.
This oxidative stress theory that you present as I have already discussed, DOES not explain why AIDS suffers, close to 100% of them test HIV positive, and those that are not positive almost never, ever present with opportunistic infections. You imply that HIV is an innocent bystander, if that is the case, why do we not see so many people that are HIV-ve showing up with immunosuppressi on?
As for proving that HIV exists, where do I start? This Perth Group nonsense that HIV does not fulfill the Koch postulates, they do not apply as they do to viruses, no virus has EVER been isolated to the Perth groups standards, however the fact that HIV has had its genome cloned 13. Fisher AG, Collalti E, Ratner L, Gallo RC and Wong-Staal F: A molecular clone of HTLV-III with biological activity. Nature (London) 316:262-265 (1985).
With regard to AIDS drugs, I think you need to do a lot more research. Firstly, where's the HIV for them to kill in the first place? We're still waiting for someone to prove it exists in humans.
Stick by your guns , i salute you. Peace.
RSS feed for comments to this post